|
26 February 2008
People have been worried about whether
vaccinations can cause epilepsy for about
fifty years. The vaccine that has caused
the most concern has been that for pertussis,
or whooping cough. Professor Simon Shorvon,
of the Institute of Neurology, University
College London, described these issues in
an article
published in
December 2007 in the journal Epilepsia.
The first concern is that developing a
high temperature after a vaccination can
trigger a febrile seizure in a child who
is prone to them. Children who have febrile
seizures have a higher risk of developing
epilepsy when they're older than children
who don't. High temperatures happen particularly
after the combined measles, mumps and rubella
(MMR) vaccine and after the combined diphtheria,
tetanus and whooping cough (DTP) vaccine.
The second fear is that the vaccine directly
causes a condition called an epileptic encephalopathy,
where seizures damage the brain and this
damage leads on to more seizures, and so
on. These are very serious conditions. A
very small number of encephalopathy cases
have been linked to whooping cough vaccinations,
but there is no consensus that "pertussis
vaccine encephalopathy" really exists.
Recent research studies into whooping cough
vaccinations and the risk of epilepsy have
all come to the same conclusion. The risk
of a febrile seizure after a vaccination
is extremely low, or about 1 in 20,000 children.
The risk of a seizure that's not due to
a temperature after a vaccination is even
lower, at about 1 in every 75,000 children.
Finally, the risk of an encephalopathy is
between 0 and 3 in a million children.
These numbers are so low it's difficult
to prove that there really is a link between
the vaccination and the encephalopathy.
Having a family history of epilepsy or febrile
seizures, or having epilepsy itself, is
therefore not a reason to avoid being vaccinated.
In 2006, a study
of 14 cases of "pertussis vaccine encephalopathy"
found that 11 out of the 14 children concerned
had a genetic mutation (SNC1A, controlling
sodium channels in brain cells) which was
instead responsible for their epilepsy.
This study thus provided a solid alternative
explanation for these cases. This raises
the possibility that all previously identified
cases of vaccine-induced encephalopathies
might in fact have a genetic basis.
Understanding that whooping cough vaccination
poses a very low risk of causing epilepsy
is important, so as to encourage as many
people as possible to take up the vaccine
for their children.
Download
Epilepsy Research UK's free information
leaflet
about vaccinations for people with epilepsy
here ( ,
41KB)
|