|
24 April 2008
One possible treatment for epilepsy in
children is the ketogenic diet, a high-fat,
low-carbohydrate regimen. This forces the
body to break down fats for energy, rather
than burning carbohydrates.
Previous studies have found that the diet
isn't effective to reduce seizure frequency
in adults. The diet requires a large consumption
of fatty foods, like oils, cream, butter,
and mayonnaise, which many people find unappealing.
The diet is very restrictive: calorie intake
and fluid intake must be accurately calculated,
and these limits must be followed. Starting
the diet usually requires a short period
with no food intake at all, usually in hospital.
The diet is therefore so intense it counts
as a medical treatment and must be prescribed.
It's thought that adults find the diet much
more difficult to follow than children (imagine
going to a restaurant with friends - what
could you eat?), and that this explains
the low success rate.
A more appealing version of the diet?
Researchers in Baltimore, USA, have been
looking into using a modified version of
the Atkins diet to treat epilepsy. The Atkins
diet is like the ketogenic diet in that
it drastically restricts the amount of carbohydrate
eaten, but unlike the ketogenic diet, total
protein, calorie and fluid intake are not
restricted, making it much more flexible.
It also doesn't require a fast to begin.
A study
has already found that a diet of this type
effectively treats epilepsy in children.
In last month's edition of the journal
Epilepsia, Professor Eric Kossoff
and colleagues at Johns Hopkins University
published
the results of their trial of the modified
Atkins diet in thirty adults with drug-resistant
epilepsy, having on average ten seizures
a week. Participants had to keep a diary
noting what they ate and how many seizures
they had.
Nearly half of the people in the trial
experienced a significant drop in seizure
frequency (fewer than half as many seizures)
after three months on the diet, though this
fell to a third of patients after six months.
If the diet worked, its effects were usually
apparent within two weeks. Most patients
lost weight during the trial. On average,
the more a patient lost weight on the diet,
the greater their reduction in seizure frequency.
However one third of people in the study
stopped the diet before reaching the three
month point because they found it too restrictive.
Professor Kossoff concluded that though
the diet didn't work for everyone, it was
effective for some adults with epilepsy,
offering a new treatment option for this
age group.
So how does the diet actually work?
Breaking down fats for energy rather than
carbohydrates alters the body's chemistry
in two ways. Firstly it increases the amounts
of chemicals called ketones in the body,
as these are by-products of metabolising
fats. (These are normally present in the
body, but in much smaller amounts.) At the
same time, the normal process of breaking
down carbohydrates for energy (which is
called glycolysis) is sidelined, and its
by-products are present in smaller amounts.
The combination of these effects alters
the way cells work in a number of ways,
which protects against seizures. Ketones
may also interact with potassium channels
in neurones, reducing their firing. Artificially
blocking carbohydrate breakdown (and thus
removing its by-products) with a drug has
also been shown
to delay the development of
seizures in rats.
A review
of recent research by on this topic was
published in
February 2008 in the journal Current
Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic
Care.
Read
more
More information about the ketogenic diet
can be found here
and here
|